Investor-Owned Utility (IOU) Wildfire Liability Shift

In August, Governor Newsom proposed a sweeping restructuring of California’s wildfire liability system that would have eliminated insurers’ ability to recover losses from utilities whose equipment caused catastrophic fires. The proposal would not have reduced wildfire losses; it would have shifted billions of dollars in utility-caused damages from utility shareholders to insurers and their policyholders, increasing pressure on homeowners premiums and undermining progress under the Sustainable Insurance Strategy, particularly in high-fire-risk communities.

PIFC worked with a broad coalition, including wildfire victims, plaintiffs’ attorneys, consumer advocates and local-government organizations, to oppose the proposal. The core provisions restricting insurer subrogation and limiting other forms of utility liability were removed during final negotiations. The substantially narrower SB 492 then died without an Assembly vote on September 1, preserving insurers’ existing subrogation rights and preventing an irresponsible transfer of utility wildfire costs to insurance policyholders.

The Assembly subsequently held three hearings examining the issues raised by the failed proposal. The October 20 hearing reviewed utility wildfire safety and mitigation; the October 28 hearing focused on utility financing, affordability and “investability”; and the October 29 joint hearing of the Utilities and Energy and Insurance Committees examined insurer subrogation. Importantly, the Assembly’s background paper recognized that any change must account for how costs would shift between utility ratepayers and insurance policyholders, as well as the consequences for the Wildfire Fund, utility financing, insurance affordability and insurance availability.

A recent Politico’s article, “Cold Days for the Wildfire Liability Deal,” reports that the utilities’ intensive campaign to secure a liability agreement before the Legislature’s membership changes has apparently stalled. Southern California Edison had identified November 15 as the practical deadline for sending legislation to Governor Newsom, but that deadline passed without an agreement. It appears that the opportunity for a Newsom-era special-session agreement is rapidly disappearing and the issue is increasingly likely to carry over to the next Governor and Legislature.

PIFC will continue to work with the Legislature and Governor’s office on this issue.

1201 K Street, Suite 1250
Sacramento, CA 95814

Phone: (916) 442-6646
Fax: (916) 446-9548

Scroll to Top